Party Of The Future

Not the past ... what the Democrats can do to succeed.

The Democratic party has gotten a little lost, perhaps led a bit too well by Joe Biden, who wandered out of a more civilized and decent time. But focusing on personalities would be wrong- there are much deeper currents at work. While it remains hard to believe that billionaires have successfully hijacked the US government on the back of demogogic appeals to the uneducated, resentful, and bigoted, that is pretty much where we are. Those billionaires are dismantling the US government as fast as humanly possible, so it is imperative for the Democratic party to regain its grip on reality, and on a winning coalition.

One of the more remarkable aspects of the new administration is just how retrograde it is. Its obsession with tariffs comes out of economics at least a century out of date. There was the weird fetishization of William McKinley, and of a replay of our colonial interlude from the late 1800's vs Greenland, maybe even Canada. There is the rollback of the regulatory state, the literal gilding of the oval office, and blithe dismissal of the last hundred years of public health advances. Rather than making America great again, it is making America backwards again, waging a bitter war against the universities and any elites not bending the knee. At this rate, we are heading backwards by the week, to perhaps before the Revolution and onwards to the depths of the royal prerogatives of Henry VIII. Who everyone says was a very great king, by the way!

It is fine to complain, (while we still can), but the more important task is to come up with a better message and coalition, so that the US can get back to looking forward, instead of backward. One way to look at the electorate is in very broad thirds- one elite third, rich and business-centric, another elite third, college educated and liberal, and one third working class. 61% of the population have some college, and 45% have a college degree of some sort. The Democratic party has increasingly moved from its base in the working class to this educated portion of the electorate, and we should own up to what is in essence a battle between two elites- the business elite and the educated elite. These have very different ethics, at least at this late phase of capitalism, when business leaders (if we can call the president that) seem just as interested in business models of grift and fraud (subprime loans, lying about fossil fuels, crypto) as those that build the country. 

Face the past

This diametric difference in ethics is why the divisiveness is at such a fever pitch now. But Democrats made a lot of mistakes as well, of which I can mention four. First, immigration. The utter loss of control at the southern border was highly unpopular. It was unfair to everyone who participated in the (highly unfair, and punishing) legal immigration system. It showed scenes of chaos and lawlessness. And it was an economic threat to everyone on the lower end of the economic spectrum- exactly those demographics the Republicans were aiming at. Second, extreme woke. With the best of intentions, liberal elites set up increasingly abstruse and extreme theaters of correctness, demanding oaths of DEI adherence from faculty, celebrating every deviance from tradition- in the political sphere, in children's literature, and the ever-extending letters of the LGBT... etc. community. All this strenuous virtue signaling was highly distracting and estranging from the bedrock of political coalition-building: unity and common sense. Third was foreign policy, principally the disastrous Afghan withdrawal. For all of the Biden administration's competence in policy over a vast gamut, this was handled very poorly. Granted, it was a cake that was baked by the Trump administration's bad deal with the Taliban, and the management on the ground was run by the military, not the White House, but whatever the cause, it looked bad to catastrophic for US standing the world. And fourth is regulatory gridlock, sapping our ability to build anything, driving up housing costs specifically.

Democrats can not just wait out the madness in Washington, and expect to be elected as the default governing party. They have to face up to ways they have strayed from a winning coalition, and think deeply about fixing it and offering a narrative and program that is both responsible and welcoming to most Americans. 

Face the future

The basic problem of US politics is that we have some unpleasant truths to face. The frontier is gone, the climate is rapidly heating up, US international power is declining. We have rapidly switched from a rising, expansive, and optimistic power to a conservative and somewhat crabby power. Our last tango with a new frontier, that of space, ended up cruelly fruitless. Robotic scientific missions have been spectacularly productive, but manned spaceflight has gone from the height of optimism to another rote exercise in great power sclerosis. There is no there there, in terms of any economic, let alone demographic, frontier. And on top of that, the planet we are thus stuck on is becoming increasingly uncomfortable, even hostile. The future is looking a bit constricted, and more so because the rich elites have lost any sense of collective dedication, and devote themselves to screwing everyone else.

Republicans have addressed these issues by lying, denial, and fantasy, powered by their rabid media sphere. Obviously, Democrats have done and will do better. The current administration makes it clearer than ever what the regulatory state is about, and it is about helping people and restraining the powerful. Democrats need to keep beating the drum that financial protection, drug regulation, food inspection, securities fraud investigation.. these are all aimed at keeping the system fair for the regular citizen. They are not "the deep state", they are not very expensive, either. They are hated only by their antagonists- fraudulent businesspeople. More broadly, inequality is culturally corrosive and calls for taxing the rich more, not less. It is insulting to working people that income from capital gains (let alone carried interest) is taxed less than labor. Everything should be taxed the same- investments, labor, estates, changes in trust membership ... everything.

Build the future

At the same time, practicality has to take a front seat. Democrats need to alter course to promise that regulators keep their eye on the ball of efficiency- fulfilling their mission without tying the economy in knots. This applies particularly to building and zoning. The most liberal areas of the country are also the most conservative, in terms of real estate. The dread of "sprawl" has excused total stasis and lack of building, even as immigrants are allowed to flood in. The result is predictable enough. 

Next, the environment. Democrats did the responsible and foresighted thing with climate bills of the Biden administration. And that helped to build up the green transition. Too little, too late, but these were broadly popular, and need to be continued. The problem is that we are still facing a difficult transition, particularly from gas cars, and on a wide spectrum of other harms such as plastics, habitat loss, resource scarcity. Democrats need to take the long view here that sustainability is the ultimate goal. Everyone can see that our current practices are not fundamentally sustainable. Catastrophes ramp up in frequency and intensity. Democrats have to be the truth-tellers here, while pointing out that building green is beneficial across the board.

Lastly, education. Our education system lays the golden eggs, powering the future of better living standards and international competitiveness. It should be easy for Democrats to make the case against the war on education being carried out by the current administration. Yet, some rebalancing is needed. We have neglected the working class end of the system, and should strengthen community colleges to provide more low-cost trades education. It is appalling that the poor are preyed upon by fly-by-night trade schools in a rich country that supposedly has high standards of education and workmanship. 

Additionally, Democrats might address the deeper malaise among the young and in the culture at large by calling for national service. Two years for young people spent on serving others would be highly beneficial. Choices could range from military to conservation corps, and medical assistance. The main condition would be that these would be non-specialized, mixed groups so that participants work with people from all walks of life in the US, (or in the Peace Corps), broadening their experience and vision of what it means to be part of this country. Call this a form of civic education, essential to a democratic society.

Democrats have the tools, and need to reach out a bit to form a bigger coalition. The right wingosphere has successfully demonized learning, knowledge, and regulation, and it is all coming home to roost in the current administration. But the regulatory state was built originally not out of a college educated coalition, but a progressive working class movement, revolted by the corruption and inequality of the gilded age. Republicans can't help themselves but serve the rich and powerful. Democrats can re-align with their natural coalition.

• In many cases, going backwards requires lying.
• A brief history of environmental law.
• Wingnuts and lies in Poland.
• Thune and the utter dereliction of congress.
• Trampling all over whatever is left of the constitution.
• Hospice, or tax cuts?
• We are leaving the global stage.
• And carrying water for Russia.
• The next frontier, after zero carbon.
• FDA as a fully captured regulator.
• Another reason why crypto is so great.