Why Would a Bacterium Commit Suicide?

Our innate immune system, including suicide of infected cells, has antecedents in bacteria.

We have a wide variety of defense from pathogens, from our skin and its coating of RNase and antimicrobial peptides, to the infinite combinatorial firepower of the adaptive immune system, which is primed by vaccines. In between is something called the innate immune system, which is built-in and static rather than adaptive, but is very powerful nonetheless. It is largely built around particular proteins that recognize common themes in pathogens, like the free RNA and DNA of viral genomes, or lipopolysaccharide that coats most bacteria. There are also internal damage signals, such as cellular proteins that have leaked out and are visible to wandering immune cells, that raise similar alarms. The alarms lead to inflammation, the gathering of immune cells, and hopefully to resolution of the problem. 

One powerful defensive strategy our cells have is apoptosis, or cellular suicide. If the signals from an incoming infection are too intense, a cell, in addition to activating its specific antiviral defenses, goes a few steps further and generates a massive inflammasome that rounds up and turns on a battery of proteases that chew up the cell, destroying it from inside. The pieces are then strewn around to be picked up by the macrophages and other cleanup crews, which hopefully can learn something from the debris about the invading pathogen. One particular target of these proteases are gasdermins, which are activated via this proteolysis and then assemble into huge pores that plant themselves into the plasma membrane and mitochondrial membranes, rapidly killing the cell by collapsing all the ion gradients across these membranes. 

A human cell committing apoptosis, and falling apart.

A recent paper showed that key parts of this apparatus is present in bacteria as well. It was both technically interesting, since they relied on a lot of AI tools to discern the rather distant relations between pathogen (that is to say, phages- the viruses of bacteria) receptors from bacteria, and generally intriguing, because suicide is generally something thought to be a civilized behavior of cells in multicellular organisms, protecting the rest of the body from spread of the pathogen. Bacteria, despite living in mucky biofilms and other kinds of colonies, are generally thought to be loners, only out for their own reproduction. Why would they kill themselves? Well, anytime they are in a community, that community is almost certainly composed of relatives, probably identical clones of a single founding cell. So it would be a highly related community indeed, and well worth protecting in this way. 

A bacterial gasdermin outruns phages infecting the cell. Two kinds of cells are mixed together here, ones without a gasdermin (green) and ones with (black). All are infected at zero time, and a vital dye is added (pink) that only gets into cells through large pores, like the gasdermin pore. At 45 minutes and after, the green (control) cells are dying and getting blown apart by escaping phages. On the other hand, the gasdermin+ cells develop pores and get stained pink, showing that they are dead too. But they don't blow up, indicating that they have shut down phage propagation.

The researchers heard that some bacteria have gasdermins, so they wondered whether they have the other parts of the system- the proteases and the sensor proteins. And indeed, they do. While traditional sequence similarity analysis didn't say so, structural comparison courtesy of the AlphaFold program showed that a protease in the same operon as gasdermin had CARD domains. These domains are signatures of caspases and of caspase interacting proteins, like the sensor proteins in the human innate immune system. They bind other CARD domains, thus mediating assembly of the large complexes that lead to inflammation and apoptosis.

Structure of the bacterial CARD domain, courtesy of AlphaFold, showing some similarity with a human CARD domain, which was not very apparent on the sequence level.

The operon of this bacterium, which encodes the whole system- gasdermin, protease (two of them), and sensor.

The researchers then raised their AI game by using another flavor of AlphaFold to predict interactions that the bacterial CARD/protease protein might have. This showed an interaction with another protein in the same operon, with similarity to NLR sensor proteins in humans, which they later confirmed happened in vitro as well. This suggests that this bacterium, and many bacteria, have the full circuit of sensor for incoming phage, activatable caspase-like protease, and then cleavable gasdermin as the effector of cell suicide.

A comparison of related operons from several other bacteria.

Looking at other bacteria, they found that many have similar systems. Some link to other effectors, rather than a pore-forming gasdermin. But most share a similar sensor-to-protease circuit that is the core of this defense system. Lastly, they also asked what triggers this whole system from the incoming phage. The answer, in this case, is a phage protein called rIIB. Unfortunately, it is not clear either what rIIB does for the phage or whether it triggers the CARD/gasdermin system by activating the bacterial NLR sensor protein, as would be assumed. What is known, however, is that rIIB has a function in defending phage against another bacterial defense system called RexAB. This it looks as though this particular arms race has ramified into a complicated back and forth as bacteria try as best they can to insure themselves against mass infection.

• The move to quash mRNA vaccines is reprehensible. A black day.
• A craven show of idiocy, weakness, and moral ignorance. But better than talking about Epstein, amiright?
• Followed by a craven, treacly exercise in begging.
• Who runs things around here?
• Injustice on the court.
• Absolutely, no way.
• Swampy Don.
• Not a quid pro quo, at all.
• Climate (and coal) graphs of the week, electricity sources of US vs China. Everyone has a very long way to go, especially China: