Saturday, January 11, 2020

Shoulder Rehab for Desk Jockeys

Repair your shoulder and keep it healthy.

This is an unusual post, on self-help. It has been revelatory for me to go through this program, and it might be useful for others who experience shoulder pain, weakness, and lack of mobility. What presents as bursitis, impingement, bicep tendonitis, or even frozen shoulder is often a deeper and more common issue of mis-alignment and weakness in the whole shoulder, with chronic cramping of various muscles, brought on by years of hunching in our modern posture of always-forward attention to computers, phones - even books! In my case it was a lab bench that started the process.

It is hard to get a straight answer or analysis about shoulder problems, since it is a complicated and unusual joint. Small issues in the anatomy can cause big issues with soft-tissue irritation and pain, which may take years to develop, but present as sudden pain and debility. But one key concept is scapular rhythym- the fluid rising motion that the scapula should be following when you reach overhead. That can't happen if the scapula is not properly aligned. Which is to say, it should be flat against the back. When sitting in a chair with a solid back, do your shoulder blades lie flat against it? Or do they stick out against it, or even align to the side, not touching the chair back at all? When standing straight with your hands falling loosely to the side, do your hands face backwards? They shouldn't. They should be facing inwards, to your hips. Bad shoulder alignment affects your whole posture, and correcting it takes time, but yields wide-ranging benefits.

The syndrome is well-described here. Knowing shoulder anatomy is somewhat helpful, but not essential, really. The basic idea of the rehab program is to strengthen the back muscles that pull the shoulder blades back into proper position, after they have been stretched and weakened for so long by the hunched posture that over-weights the front-pulling muscles. The first step is to restore mobility and range of motion to all the muscles around the shoulder. So start with a series of stretches. Older people especially need lots of stretching to keep muscles working properly. Both the stretching and the strengthening would then be a life-long program, given that activities with forward posture tend to also be a life-long love affair.
  • Door stretch: with arms up and elbows half-way up, like a stick-up, lay them against a door frame and push through forward with your body/chest to open up the shoulder and chest.
  • Do the same thing with each arm singly, stretching each arm to 45 degrees back from the plane of the body.
  • Facing against a wall, with one arm, reach straight up, then work the arm back through a full circle, turning sideways and stretching against the wall as you go around. Finish with a cross-stretch with the arm going in the front across your chest.
  • With a broom handle, place it straight up behind one shoulder with the opposite hand, and reach back to it over the top with the same hand. Then pull forward and up with the opposite hand till you feel a stretch in the subscapularis.
  • Brachiation: from a pullup bar, just hang for a few seconds with as much weight as possible.
  • During the day, remember to stand and open up your shoulders periodically. Sometimes you can even get a crack out of your sternum, if you have been hunched for a while. A phone app reminder every 10 minutes may be helpful. 
  • Against a shelf or seat about waist high, lay the front of your arms on it, and lower your trunk till you feel a thorough stretch, then lift about half your weight with your arms- repeat 6 times.
  • Hitch arms together behind your back, grasping each opposite elbow. Bend trunk to the sides, stretching the obliques, bend forward and back. Turn neck to each side as far as possible, holding stretch.
  • With your back towards a shelf or bar about shoulder-high, grab with your hands, and lower your body to stretch the front of the shoulder. The aim should be to get about horizontal with the arms going straight back, or slightly lower. Next, using the same shelf and position, bend each elbow in turn and lay it/forearm on the shelf behind you, lowering the body again. This is a more intense stretch with the same goal.
  • On the floor, on a mat or carpet, make sure your scapula is flat against the ground. Then make angels, swinging arms through full range from sides to overhead, 10X; alternate arms, 10X more.

The next step is strengthening, to counteract the typically forward- directed actions we take all day, and make the posture changes permanent. There are many helpful videos and other instructions on the internet.
  • With face down, on a support like a weight-lifting bench or table, lift the arms straight out and up to the sides, as far as possible. Start with no weights, then add weights as possible. 3X 12 repetitions.
  • Same posture, but with elbows out and arms pointed forward. 3X 12 repetitions
  • Rowing against resistance- using a rowing machine, or resistance band, or rope, pull about 1/2 your weight, 10 times at least. Start slowly with this exercise, as it can cause pain at first.
  • With a relatively heavy resistance band, stretch between your hands in front, about shoulder-wide. While stretching apart as much as you can, work your hands up and down a wall, from arms fully up to fully down, 12X. Start slowly with this one as well.
  • With a relatively light resistance band, extend arms straight forward and pull wide to the sides, out as far as possible, 12X. While you are at it, while extended, swing your arms back over your head and down to your lower back, for a good stretch.
  • With a resistance band anchored to a pole or wall to the side, hold your elbows down at your side with hands straight forward. Pull the resistance band 90 degrees sideways, 20X each direction, strengthening both arms in the rotatory cuff.
  • When all that is working OK, raise weights from the side, standing position, to fully overhead, about 10 pounds each side, 10X, strengthening deltoids.
  • When all that is working OK, add push-ups and pull-ups.

When walking, attend to posture, leading with the feet, not the shoulders. When sitting, attend to posture, laying scapula flat against the seat.

That is the full program, though many other exercises and stretches can be added. Much of the damage and pain from this syndrome can be assigned to the anterior of the rotator cuff, (supraspinatus, subscapularis, and bicep tendon), and this program will not reverse the damage, but it will prevent further damage and allow effective operation of the shoulder without relying on, and irritating, the front of the rotator cuff so much. I think this issue is endemic and under-recognized. Much of the enthusiasm for muscle "trigger points" and deep massage comes from cramped muscles in the shoulder, neck and back regions. But typically, regular stretching is a better and longer-term solution, even if trigger point release provides rapid relief from pain. Every muscle can be stretched, so when you notice one giving pain or limiting range of motion, do some research on how to loosen it up, and add that to your program.

2 comments:

Burk said...

AAOS has a helpful page on this, and an especially thorough set of exercises.

Burk said...

There have been a couple of revolutionary books in this field that I recommend.

Bulletproof your shoulder- This is well written and researched- a comprehensive, but minimal program for strengthening and stretching the rotator cuff.

Shoulder pain- This is total crank territory, poorly organized and written. But the central recommendation of dead-hanging is spot-on- a key addition to the exercises above, to loosen up the shoulder and resolve degenerative impingement-related shoulder pain.