Addiction, Exorcism, and the American Dream

Review of Beautiful Boy.

Why is drug addiction such a widespread and dangerous scourge? A lot has been made of the despair of the working class especially in declining rural areas- a crisis of meaning and survival at the short end of the capitalist system. But there is higher anxiety everywhere in our unequal, precarious, and atomized system. Even in wealthy Marin, where the story of this movie originates, parents are in what seems like fight to the death to get their offspring into colleges to fulfil an overwhelming set of competitive expectations. No wonder young adults, even when well-to-do, already feel themselves in a rat race which it would be pleasant to check out of, momentarily. Then add in the viciousness of modern drugs like crystal meth and fentanyl, and you have a lethal witches' brew.

Still from the movie. Timothee Chalamet playing Nic Sheff, and Steve Carrel playing David Sheff.

We used to regard Russia as a demographic basket case, with declining population riven with alcoholism in the wake of the Soviet collapse. Now we are facing a similar downward dynamic- a social rot punctuated by self-destruction through drugs and suicide. The ultimate source seems to be broad insecurity, which was precisely the point of the economic and cultural reforms of the recent Republican epoch, starting with Ronald Reagan. The benefits of competition and division were trumpeted, and the rich were feted as job creators and entrepreneurs, and given absurd benefits like a tax rate on investment profits half as high as the rate on labor income. Companies developed an ideology of serving profits to the exclusion of all other goals, which meant the destruction of stable life schedules, stable jobs, and stable communities. The Reagan era gave rise to wide-spread homelessness, the ultimate warning to labor to keep its head down. And a broad reduction of safety nets of all sorts, from corporate pensions to onerous rules for welfare, which was divided into a puzzle of ungenerous programs.

How ironic, then, that Donald Trump offered to fix all this for workers, restoring the greatness and jobs of America. Who suspected that he came from a Republican tradition whose first order of business, when given power, has been to hand money to the rich? Who suspected that his policy ideas came more from the tabloid headlines of the 80's and 90's (not to say his fascist forebears in the 30's) than from the issues the working class face today? Who suspected that the greatest epoch in American history, after World War 2, was actually our period of highest taxation, culminating in, not coincidentally, the Apollo space program, which was hardly a capitalist venture?

Reagan, George W. Bush, and Trump each cloaked themselves as shamans for an anxious society, ready to exorcise the demons of economic malaise and insecurity, as well as those of Vietnam. While Democrats offered laundry lists of melioration, Republicans could do no such thing, their object being to strengthen hierarchy and help the better-off. They have instead lighted on a more tribally / religiously tinged approach, offering a broad ideology of conservatism (however radical the implementation, and departure from the existing system) and order, which would by some mystery of compassionate conservatism redound to the benefit of all after generous payouts to the few.

On the military front, they authored a series of military misadventures that climaxed with the criminal debacle in Iraq. On the economic front, they pushed hard-line capitalism as the cure-all to bring economic growth, starving the state with deregulation, outsourcing, and bitter budget / deficit battles as a purgatorial nostrum that would rejuvenate an ailing system. Curiously, however, the treatment never worked for the middle class and poor, keeping them economically static and ever more insecure, while the rich and super-rich pocketed all the proceeds.

Economic vitality needs some dynamism and destruction. But people and communities need stability and a basic level of egalitarianism to feel human and have basic freedoms. The founders foresaw that rising wealth and inequality might make of America the same class-ridden culture they had fled in Europe. Their hopes were tied not just to the new republican structure they were building, but also, in economic terms, to the frontier- the jobs-for-all program of its day- which would continue to offer all Americans (and immigrants from all over the world) the option of a decent and hard-working living, preventing excessive inequality.

Now the frontier is gone, the population continues to rise, and the only solution from the "conservative" right is to squeeze the middle class and poor relentlessly in a spiral of anxiety that drives everyone to work and live under ever less humane conditions. We need a better balance that builds more unifying social structures and public goods, reels back the excesses of extreme capitalism, and gives people breathing space and freedom to dream of being more than cogs in a machine.